The Joseph Hall Cottage Historic Cape May

Some homes have addresses. This one has a legacy.
Built in 1868, the Joseph Hall Cottage is one of Cape May’s most recognized Victorian landmarks — a masterwork of Italianate gingerbread architecture nestled in the heart of the National Historic Landmark District. With its signature golden facade, intricate carved porch detail, original entry staircase, and ornamental ironwork gardens, 645 Hughes Ave is not just a place to stay. It is a piece of American architectural history.
The cottage is making its debut as a vacation rental this summer, managed by Eastcote Homestays. Interiors are currently being curated with new furnishings ahead of the 2026 rental season; listing photos will be updated prior to first guest arrival. The bones — original hardwood floors, period fireplaces, soaring entry hall — are extraordinary, and the finished space will be nothing less.

The Space

Five beautifully appointed bedrooms sleep up to 10 guests in comfort:
• 1 King suite
• 4 Queen bedrooms
The wraparound Victorian porch with rocking chairs sets the tone the moment you arrive. Inside, original architectural details — carved woodwork, period mantlepieces, generous room proportions — have been lovingly preserved. This is a home that rewards slow mornings and lingering evenings.

Outside

The fully fenced rear yard offers privacy rare for in-town Cape May. Grill out, rinse off at the outdoor shower after the beach, and let the evening unfold on the porch as the neighborhood lights up at dusk. Off-street parking for multiple vehicles is included — a genuine luxury in Cape May in July.

Location

Hughes Streer sits at the quiet heart of the historic district. The beach is a short walk. Washington Street Mall — Cape May’s celebrated pedestrian promenade of shops, galleries, and restaurants — is steps away. Everything that makes Cape May one of the East Coast’s most beloved destinations is at your door.
One well-behaved dog is welcome.
Interior furnishings are being refreshed for the 2026 rental season and listing photos will be updated prior to first guest arrival. Guests booking now are reserving one of Cape May’s most iconic properties at the ground floor of its new chapter.

~ Photos shown reflect the property’s current configuration and real estate listing imagery. Interior furnishings are being curated ahead of the 2026 rental season and updated photography will be posted prior to first guest arrival. The architectural character, exterior, and grounds shown are accurate representations of the property.